Christie ([info]karayzieho) wrote,
@ 2008-04-11 12:41:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Unathleticism
I am probably the most unathletic athlete around. I have confidence, passion and discipline, and a knack for activities that require coordination like darts, skiing, tennis, and motorcycling, but when it comes down to raw athleticism I come up shorter than short shorts on an oompa loompa (wow, mega dumb analogy).

I only mean to compare myself to athletes because I'm in relatively good shape compared to the general population. But take, for example, where I was at when I was in my best shape ever: a 30 minute, 3 mile run would have my heart rate at 150 by at least a few minutes into it, 160 ten minutes into it, and 170 twenty minutes into it. The whole time I'd be sweaty and generally unable to talk, and at the end of the run I'd usually be feeling nauseated (yet also elated at having just kicked my own ass), with a heart rate around 180.

A heart rate training guide I read recently seemed to encourage athletes to work up to a point where they could keep their heart rate at this kind of level for an extended period of time. I'm doing it, already, only the quantity of work it takes me to get to that level is minuscule compared to most. Although, I feel like I could keep my own high heart rate all day long. Like when my spin class instructor talked about training at a 140 bpm heart rate for one hour, I was like, psssshaw, no problem. Only I'd be left in the dust if I were in an actual bicycle race with people.

Does this mean I need to do more cardio, or do my muscles need to be stronger so that the work isn't as hard? I'd like to improve my athleticism so I could potentially be more competitive in a group bicycle ride.



(Post a new comment)


[info]mrcrash
2008-04-11 10:48 pm UTC (link)
If your heart rate is climbing like that, you're well past your lactate threshold. There are all kinds of different guides out there that determine what your approximate max heart rate is, but we're all different. A common formula is below:

Max Heart Rate (Female) = 209 - Age * 0.7

I'm not gonna give out your age, but let's say that gave you a max heart rate of 180 :) Lactate threshold is generally in the neighborhood of 80% Max Heart Rate, so that's right around where you want to keep things when you want to do any activity for an extended period of time. If your max was 180, threshold might be around 144. If your activity puts you over 150, your heart rate will just take off if you try to maintain that level.

As far as whether it means you need to do more cardio or physically stronger, I'd say all of the above - that extra strength is gonna be good for muscling a Suzuki around at race speeds, and at limiting injury should you get off again :)

I've been cardio only since starting triathlon, and it seems to be working pretty well!

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]juniorbird
2008-04-11 11:30 pm UTC (link)
Totally on-target. As depressing as this is, you probably should be doing more *slow* cardio, maybe even walking or hiking, until you develop a bit more endurance. You should not be engaging in regular exercise that puts your heart rate that high.

This could all be an artifact of the fact that you've gained most of your muscle through lifting; you might have built the wrong kind of muscle for endurance. This is not uncommon in weightlifters. More, manageable, endurance activities will build up more of the slower-burning muscle fibers. Anecdotally, I have a few friends who suggest yoga might help as well. Pilates could also be worth a try.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]friedlinguini
2008-04-12 04:06 am UTC (link)
Going the other direction, have you tried pushing intensity for shorter durations?

Linky

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]juniorbird
2008-04-12 05:47 am UTC (link)
When I ran, I found interval training to be tremendously effective in improving both my endurance and speed. However, if all she has is fast-twitch muscles, she may find that the intervals she needs to keep her heart rate at safe levels are too long to provide benefit.

But it is worth a try, the example exercise in Fried's linked article is a good one, as is sprinting one straightaway in a quarter mile track while walking the rest. See if your heart rate gets too high too quick there.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…